Welcome to this week’s edition of “MI&S Datacenter Podcast” I’m Patrick Moorhead with Moor Insights & Strategy, and I am joined by co-hosts Matt, Will, and Paul. We analyze the week’s top datacenter and datacenter edge news. We talk compute, cloud, security, storage, networking, operations, data management, AI, and more!
2:18 Nutanix Is Moving & Shaking With Dell & Lenovo (Matt)
9:14 Dell Tech World Networking & Edge Updates
17:23 SB1047 Dangerous To AI
23:35 Microsoft Build – Cobalt Is My CoPilot
30:18 IBM Introduces Concert
34:09 AI Reads Your Brain
38:40 Earnings Season Is In Full Flight
Nutanix Is Moving & Shaking With Dell & Lenovo
Dell Tech World Networking & Edge Updates
https://x.com/WillTownTech/status/1792969229245001981
SB1047 Dangerous To AI
https://legiscan.com/CA/text/SB1047/2023B1047
https://x.com/Moor_Quantum/status/1791955456304226748
Microsoft Build – Cobalt Is My CoPilot
IBM Introduces Concert
AI Reads Your Brain
https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-024-01451-4
Earnings Season Is In Full Flight
https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7201683734104875008/
https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7201682139472408576/
Disclaimer: This show is for information and entertainment purposes only. While we will discuss publicly traded companies on this show. The contents of this show should not be taken as investment advice.
Matt Kimball: … we’re going to go live. Hey, we are suddenly live. Good afternoon, good morning, good evening, good night. Depending on where you are in the world because we have a global audience. This is episode 24 of More Insights & Strategy DataCenter Podcast. I am this week’s host, my name’s Matt Kimble. Let me introduce you to the host of the next one, Will Townsend and the estimable, is that a word? Estimable? Paul Smith-Goodson.
Paul Smith-Goodson: I’ll accept it. Yeah.
Matt Kimball: I like that. He is the smart one. So you’ve got, what I like to think of as the beauty, the brains, and then we have Will, and I’m not sure what Will is yet, but we’ll figure that one out.
Will Townsend: The beast. The beast.
Matt Kimball: The beast. Here we go. Hey, we got a lot to talk about. Episode 24, we’re going to do this in 10 minutes or less. Episode 24, a lot of news over the last couple of weeks that we want to tie off on. Before I start, please be sure to hit the like button. I’m going to tell you this now and later. And also, don’t trust a single word we say as far as using this for investment purposes. That’s really important to take note of because none of us, while we all look smart, we’re not. So yeah, there’s that. So listen guys, you had a good couple of weeks. We’ve been on the road, going to Think going to Dell Tech World, going to Microsoft Build, Nutanix NEXT everywhere. Everyone’s doing well. Are we ready for fun podcast?
Will Townsend: I am so ready. It’s been nice to be home for a week, Matt, but I am back on the road next week, three weeks in a row in Vegas. So Cisco Live, Zscaler Zenith Live and HPE Discover. So I am already hydrating, I’m already taking my vitamins and I’m staying very, very focused.
Matt Kimball: And already breathing in some clean oxygen, so as you go through those smoke-filled casinos.
Will Townsend: Mm-hmm.
Matt Kimball: I got you. All right, well listen, like I said, we got a lot to talk about. Nutanix, Dell, SB 1047. I’m going to guess that’s a Paulism. Microsoft, IBM, AI, and then earnings season. So let’s jump in. I’m trying to get more Paul-like in my headlines, so let’s see how this works out. First one, Nutanix is moving and shaking with Dell and Lenovo. So here’s the deal. A few months ago, Lenovo signed an agreement of partnership or entered into a partnership with Cisco whereby they would co-engineer solutions, HCI solutions, hybrid cloud solutions that were targeted at easily deploying and standing up and managing within an enterprise’s organization. Done wonderfully with that. In fact, at Nutanix .NEXT, they talked about a new appliance, if you will, called GPT-in-a-Box whereby you could stand up a gen AI environment pretty quickly on Cisco and Nutanix hardware. That was doing very well.
In the meantime, there’ve been some market dynamics that have taken place with other virtualization providers and hybrid cloud providers and HCI providers, who won’t name them by name, but some market dynamics. VMware. And with these dynamics, I think other organizations have found, or vendors have found opportunities here. So in the last couple of weeks, Nutanix entered into similar agreements with Dell and Lenovo. With Dell, they announced it at .NEXT and Lenovo was kind of a softer announcement, but it’s the same kind of story. Co-engineer, a turnkey solution that an enterprise IT organization can deploy, can stand up an HCI environment, hybrid cloud, private cloud environment, gen AI environment with just a few clicks of the mouse and they’re off and running. And really kind of becomes a control plane for infrastructure.
I love what they’re doing here, I know what they’re doing. As VMware sees attrition kind of in the kind of the, yeah, ESMB, right? Enterprise, commercial enterprise and down market segments, Nutanix is a logical landing place. So this is good for Nutanix because it provides ready-made solutions. Also, good for Dell and Lenovo because it’s easy for them to, or it gives them another kind of leverage point in with those companies. I don’t know if you guys follow this stuff at all, but if you have any thoughts, either on what Nutanix is doing or what you’ve seen with VMware, it’d be interesting to hear.
Will Townsend: Well, hey Matt, I’ve got a question. I know that you spend a lot of time with Nutanix and I’m super impressed with what they’re doing with big tech, right? So you mentioned Cisco, now Dell and Lenovo. I mean, what is it about Nutanix that’s so special? Is it their IP? Because they’re a relatively new company or am I wrong on that point?
Matt Kimball: Yeah, I mean, they’re new in traditional standards, they’re not in tech standards. They’ve been around since, I think it’s 15 is when they came out with their first HCI solution. So they’ve been around about 10 years. What is interesting about them, they are the pioneer for HCI, right? They took virtualization and they saw these challenges in storage and compute and said, “We have an idea.” And their focus from day one has been simple, and that’s why organizations use them. That’s why they’re so popular, as you look kind of down market into the mid-market, small enterprise, they’re so darn popular because their technology is so easy to deploy and so easy to manage.
So if I want virtualization and I want to be able to manage my environment and do it, but I don’t have the resources to spend on a VMware certified engineer or somebody else, Nutanix has been such a great solution to fill that need. And as the market’s progressed and they’ve progressed, that portfolio has gotten bigger and bigger. They’ve gone from compute and storage to compute and storage and networking to compute and storage and networking. Hey, and what about database and what about seamless cloud migrations and multi cloud migrations? So it’s really kind of expanded their capabilities, but always with that focus on simple.
So it allows a small company to act like a cloud provider essentially, and that is a really great value add. VMware has been far more sophisticated in how they do things, far more complex. And I don’t mean that in a negative way or a positive way. They just have been, they’ve taken a different approach. And so they’ve had these two approaches and they both staked out their claim. One kind of gravitated more toward the larger enterprise, one gravitated more toward the smaller enterprise. But with all these licensing issues going on with VMware, Nutanix sees a real opportunity. And Dell, Lenovo these companies, I think they’re seeing these same opportunities, which is why you’re seeing these partnerships.
Will Townsend: Yeah, cool. Thanks for the education on that.
Matt Kimball: Hey, hey, that’s what I’m here for. Teacher Matt. Boom.
Paul Smith-Goodson: I think as more details come out, the impact and benefits of this partnership will become clearer. They all look great for both of them.
Matt Kimball: Yeah, really are. And I think leading with AI, or having AI as kind of that killer app, if you will, is a good entry into a lot of companies. So it’s going to be fun to watch.
Will Townsend: It is.
Paul Smith-Goodson: They need to do a pretty good integration and performance and strong market positioning.
Matt Kimball: Well that’s what I like about what they’re doing, Paul. It’s not, a lot of times these partnerships are really just take our software, install it on your hardware and call it a bundle. And there’s really nothing more. They’re actually going in and like in the case of Cisco, they integrated Intersight, which is their management cloud I guess you would call it, or management utility, cloud-based. They’ve integrated that in with Nutanix’s management platform and they’ve allowed greater levels of integration and management of the Nutanix environment. Dell’s taking a similar approach, I suspect Lenovo will too. So I mean, they’re really going in and delivering a deeper level of value than just a, “Take this and make it run and hopefully it’ll be okay.” So I like that.
Paul Smith-Goodson: It’s important that they’ve got seamless transitions with the customers and they got to maintain their scalability and flexibility.
Matt Kimball: Without a doubt. So listen, I took seven minutes longer than I was supposed to on that, so-
Will Townsend: We’ve got three minutes to go. Come on, Matt.
Matt Kimball: With that said, let’s move on to Mr. Pissy, Will Townsend. So Will, Dell Tech World, networking and edge updates. Hit us.
Will Townsend: And I’m sure Matt, you’re going to want to jump in here too because you were able to attend towards the tail end of the Dell Tech World. But surprise, surprise, the theme was AI, go figure, right?
Matt Kimball: No way.
Will Townsend: And both Mr. Dell and Jeff Clarke, the COO used the event as an opportunity to speak to what they’re doing with what they’re calling Dell’s AI factory. And that includes a host of announcements around compute, storage as well as networking and an AI PC. So what I’m going to hit are sort of the networking and the edge highlights. So Broadcom was center on stage with, I think it was with Mr. Clarke, and both companies spoke to their collaboration, how they’re expanding ethernet. And this is something that you and I and Patrick, our founder, have wax nostalgia about on Forbes. We’ve published an article around what Broadcom is doing as well as Marvell, but this was sort of bringing it all into full focus. And so there were a couple of products announced. There was a Dell power switch that’s using the Tomahawk 5 chipset and Broadcom claims it’s going to double performance over its prior generation silicon. And this is super important to feed these very power hungry AI workloads, and also be power efficient at the same time.
And then there was also an announcement around a new power edge solution that supports Broadcom’s 400 gig PCIe Gen 5 ethernet adapter. So that complements that power switch, and I forget the names, it’s a jumble of alphanumeric characters, but at the end of the day, it’s all about improving performance, improving latency, and doing all that very power efficiently. So I’d like to see Dell do more. They also spoke about what they’re doing with their SONiC distribution and certainly there are benefits there. Dell, it’s leaning into its DNA. Dell is about open source and SONiC does that for Dell as a networking operating system. I’ll be publishing a research note that sort of captures this and native edge that I’m going to talk about in a minute. But I would like to see Dell do a little more with networking beyond leveraging the latest merchant silicon and having their own kind of flavor of a SONiC distribution. I don’t know, Matt, I mean, am I being too critical there?
Matt Kimball: You’re never too critical, Will.
Will Townsend: Well, as analysts, we’re paid to be critical, right?
Matt Kimball: Yeah. There’s a fine line between how much a company like Dell leans into delivering that plumbing solution. And I don’t mean plumbing in a derogative way, it’s just as a compute guy, networking was always mysticism and-
Will Townsend: Right. Or maybe even a second thought, right? Because Dell built such a market share leadership position with compute and storage, right?
Matt Kimball: They have. But the question is… And when you’ve leaned so heavily on compute and storage, right? Networking is absolutely critical to AI. The plumbing is absolutely critical. How fast can you move data from point A to point B? But while you’ve staked your fortunes on compute and networking, at what point do you start butting up against preferred solutions that are already done? This is where I get a little, I struggle a little bit, right? If you look at a company like Cisco that is so well kind of entrenched in enterprise networking and is the solution of choice for a lot of companies, and you’ll go into a lot and you’ll see Cisco switches and Cisco networking gear right along Dell servers. It’s like at what point are you pushing too hard or essentially pushing against pushing a rope? And I don’t know where that line is for Dell. They have to have some kind of solution. They have to have a complete end to end. But do you want to push so hard on your customers your own solution that you put other sales at risks because you’re pushing too hard on one, where maybe they already have established vendors in there? I don’t know. It’s a … space for me.
Will Townsend: It’s interesting. It’s interesting. Hey, well let me hit NativeEdge real quick too. So I’m not sure if either of you have heard of NativeEdge. But I spent time with Dell, and I don’t recall Matt if you were there as well. It was in Austin. There was sort of a Dell AI day.
Matt Kimball: Yeah.
Will Townsend: Yeah, you were there. And I had a chance to speak with the NativeEdge folks. And so NativeEdge is something that’s been out for about a year. Dell acquired a company called Cloudify in early ’23 and used it as a basis to launch NativeEdge. And there was a project, Dell likes to use these interesting project names, but it became NativeEdge. And what Dell positions Data Edge as is the only edge operations platform that can scale to securely provision devices and manage them across multi cloud environments. And I’ve seen some demo activity on this and I think truly, Dell has found something that’s going to be very viable. When you think about what they’re doing to ease the provisioning of devices by issuing credentials ahead of time. There’s a lot of root of trust that’s built into the silicon level of what they’re doing here. And from my perspective, as we start to see AI workloads move from the cloud down to on-premise and on-device, Dell could be in a great position to capitalize on what they’re doing with NativeEdge.
Matt Kimball: I’ll tell you, the two days of that summit they had back down in Austin, they take you through everything. Again, AI was the focus, but that edge session was the most interesting one to me. I’m with you. I thought the approach they were taking around provisioning, securing, managing, updating in real time, the whole from end to end, it felt like they had the edge story kind of sussed out pretty well. And not just the story, but the technology behind it as well. I was pretty impressed with what they were doing.
Paul Smith-Goodson: They’re bringing Airspan and Druid in also, I think.
Matt Kimball: Airspan, Airgap, yeah. Yeah. Paul, we should probably set up Paul on a call with them too, be pretty impressed with how they’ve built this solution. Well, I don’t want to take from, but how they built the solution out or acquired it and then integrated it in. But it’s literally a kind of sit back from your house in Austin and manage your edge environment with just a couple of clicks. It’s so simple. Let me reframe that. It’s so complex, but they’ve abstracted every bit of complexity from administrator’s kind of hands, which I think is fantastic.
Will Townsend: Yeah, for sure.
Matt Kimball: Sorry. Okay, let’s talk about SB 1047. We’ve all been talking about SB 1047, haven’t we?
Will Townsend: Isn’t that Beverly Hills 90210 maybe?
Paul Smith-Goodson: My neighbors asked me about-
Matt Kimball: It’s Paul Smith-Goodson, 1047, dangerous to AI. What are you talking about?
Paul Smith-Goodson: Let me decode this. SB 1047 is a bill that California’s looking at to further regulate AI. Kind of worries me when we get so many regulations, especially government and state regulations.
Will Townsend: People that don’t know what they’re doing or understand the technology is evidenced by the Facebook hearings from a few years ago on Capitol Hill, right?
Matt Kimball: Yeah.
Paul Smith-Goodson: I mean we’ve got a lot of internal organizational type safety regulations within the ecosystem. I think we’ve got a US executive order that I think Biden put out, safe and secure and trustworthy development. And that looks at guidelines for federal agencies, how they can use it. California, Colorado and other states have got other laws that regulate AI and automated decision making. There’s a lot of task forces, but this one looks like it’s targeting large language models and generative AI. It’s gone through a couple of sessions. I don’t know when they’re actually going to vote on the final bill, but my concerns are that the way they’ve got this structured, there’s a lot of companies, AI companies within California. You look at the AI Alliance, it’s got over a hundred companies in the alliance, open source alliance with IBM and Meta. There’s a lot of those companies, smaller companies that are in California, and I think that this may put an undue burden on them because it is targeting the larger models. They’ve got a restriction that takes in if it’s been trained with something with 10 to the 26th power and it’s going to fall under these regulations. And I think we’re getting pretty close to it now. I don’t know exactly where we’re at. I think a lot of the models have been trained with 10 to the 23rd power or 10 to the 24th. You look at a brain, our compute power is about 10 to the 14th power. That’s like …
Will Townsend: Oh, wow.
Paul Smith-Goodson: You know?
Matt Kimball: Wow. Not all of us.
Paul Smith-Goodson: But my big concern is, I’ve got two concerns. One is we don’t want to put restrictions on something that’s going to cause us to lose the advantage to China because China’s doing a lot of AI research on military and especially autonomous AI applications. So when you start getting up to… I mean, AI really can’t do anything… I think we talked about this once before. An AI model really can’t do anything harmful to humanity. Do really weird things like trying to pretend like it doesn’t know we’re testing it and stuff like that. Unless AI becomes self-aware, and we’re so far away from models of being self-aware, we’re like two decades away. We don’t even know how our own consciousness work. So I don’t think they should rush the judgment on this, but they’re going to pass it, so I think it needs to be moderated a little bit.
Matt Kimball: Paul, do you see companies leaving California over something like this?
Paul Smith-Goodson: I can see them doing that. Yeah, if there’s a lot of restrictions on it. There’s a tendency for other states to jump in on things like this too. But yeah, if you’ve got a lot of restrictions, I mean resources are going to end up putting a lot of time and trying to meet the standards, doing the testing, taking away from doing advanced research.
Matt Kimball: Yeah, I’m sorry. I’m trying to make us look cool. It just seems to me… Oh, there we go. All right. I figured it out. Yeah, it just seems to me if I’m a startup that’s kind of building the next big thing or working with data and AI and the state I’m working in is super restrictive, there are 49 other states that I can consider and maybe the number’s more realistically like 10 other states, but there are still other states that can consider that-
Paul Smith-Goodson: Yeah, worst case is that they don’t move from state to state, they move to another country
Matt Kimball: Or that too. Yeah. Yeah.
Paul Smith-Goodson: I mean, when you’ve got 2 and $3 million packages, I mean, pretty easy to move around.
Matt Kimball: Yeah, that’s a good point. Yeah.
Will Townsend: But thinking along those lines, I mean, when you look at the European Union, look at GDPR and look at all the regulations in Europe, I mean, would you want to relocate to Europe? I don’t think so, but where else would you go? Middle East?
Matt Kimball: Argentina.
Will Townsend: Argentina, Brazil? You know, who knows, right? But it’s interesting.
Matt Kimball: And it’s not just so easy as just kind of packing up and moving, right? You’ve got a talent base you have to consider. Do you have those folks you can recruit and bring with you? Yeah. But anyway, it’s an interesting challenge. Hey, so let’s move on because I’m the worst defender, but we’re not moving at the pace that we need to be at, so let’s move on. Next one. This is where I really tried to channel my inner Paul, talking about Microsoft Build with Cobalt of my Copilot.
Paul Smith-Goodson: I love the title. You remember that old movie?
Matt Kimball: Thank you. I killed two birds with one stone here. My big takeaway from both of these, from Microsoft Build was involved in both of these Cobalt, the ARM-based CPU that Microsoft is built for Azure in Copilot, obviously their AI tool that is meant to-
Paul Smith-Goodson: Your cleverness was on the scale on this.
Matt Kimball: What’s that? Oh, thank you.
Paul Smith-Goodson: Your cleverness was off the scale on this.
Matt Kimball: Can I quote you on that?
Paul Smith-Goodson: Yeah, sure.
Matt Kimball: I’m putting that on my LinkedIn profile. So first is Cobalt. Cobalt 100 goes into public preview. Microsoft is claiming somewhere in the order of 40% better performance than any other ARM CPU that’s on the market. I think they’re trying to include the other cloud providers as well as the merchant Silicon that’s out there. Interestingly, I met with the team, really sharp bunch of guys, but they’re going to be aggressive with this just like AWS has been with Graviton and Oracle has been with Ampere, and we expect Google will be with Axion. But super aggressive, no workloads are off limits. There are obvious affinities for Cobalt, but it’s going to be fun to watch. I know that Graviton is about 25% of Amazon’s install, or AWS’s install base right now or deployment right now. Be curious to see if Cobalt reaches that level with Microsoft, but really cool technology. They’ve got a road map, they’ve got a vision, they know where they’re taking this thing. It’s going to be fun to watch and see how this impacts the X86 players.
That was part, my first takeaway. My second was Copilot, and I’ve always thought of Copilot as, hey, help you summarize meeting notes or help you summarize an email thread that’s going around, and that’s really good. One of the demos I got was from the GitHub team, and it was how Copilot actually helps in the app dev world through prompt engineering. Write a function that does this, write a function that does that. It’s incredible to see the amount, the levels of productivity that you can drive within an organization with a tool. And I’m not saying Copilot is the end all be all. That’s what I saw, but how much productivity you can drive across an organization, whether you’re an engineer, whether you’re a marketeer, whether you’re a financial guy or woman, there is so much to be gained from this.
It’s going to be shocking to see a couple years out, every enterprise not using a tool like this to help them in their day-to-day. The GitHub thing blew me away. When you think about how you break down software development and you build out different modules and pieces and do your regression testing and integration testing and all that. When I saw the demo they gave and kind of apply that to what I know, it’s incredible how much faster you can get to product, get to value, get to solution through a tool like Copilot. It’s not going to replace people, but it’s going to replace a lot of the mundane, which is where we spend a lot of our time. Really, really cool solution.
Will Townsend: I think, Matt, it’s got the potential to really drive innovation in software design because to your point, so much of coding… And I know this because one of my daughters studied computer science and she doesn’t like to do it now. In fact, she’s a program manager, but so much of coding is, there’s a lot of mundane activity, to your point, and that sucks up a lot of the time that can be spent on innovation and creativeness and that sort of thing.
So not only does it sound like something like Copilot can drive faster time to market, but I think it’s going to really drive innovation. And to your point, there has to be human beings involved in that process. It’s not typing a prompt and it spits out the code and you’re done. It’s going to really enable creativity for programmers, so that’s super exciting.
Matt Kimball: It should, yes. I remember having this discussion though when iPhones first came out with an old colleague of ours who I used to work with around the impact it was going to have on kids. And his position was, “Well, when you look at the iPhone and Google and what you can do, it’s going to free up their time to be more creative in other areas.” And 10 years later, it’s really just doom scrolling.
Will Townsend: Big time.
Matt Kimball: I don’t see the creativity, but it certainly has that potential and hopefully that’s what we end up seeing. And the numbers that we’re showing around productivity, time saved and value. There’s a hesitancy among smart people who develop software to want to use tools, because, “I can do everything myself, right? I’m the smartest guy in the world.” It’s amazing. They showed some number of the percent of developers that have tried it that saw immediate value in it, and it was like 86% or something like that, immediately realized, “Oh, this is a game changer for me.” So for a bunch of really smart people who know they’re really smart people, that’s another nice way of saying they have big egos, to realize what they can gain out of this, it says a lot about what it’s going to be able to do. But I don’t want to belabor, that was only four minutes, so we did pretty good on that topic.
Will Townsend: Awesome.
Matt Kimball: Paul, do you want to add anything in before I move on to-
Paul Smith-Goodson: Yeah, we can move.
Matt Kimball: Okay, let’s move on to, yeah, Will we got to work on your creativity, okay?
Will Townsend: I know.
Matt Kimball: Moving on to IBM introduces Concert. You could have done so much.
Will Townsend: I know.
Paul Smith-Goodson: There’s so much material there.
Will Townsend: Yeah, you two are raising the bar. So I’m going to raise the bar on the next podcast, but I’m going to hit this really quick because I did publish a research note yesterday to our website, More Insights & Strategy, so go check that out. So we are in the thick of event season, as we were saying earlier, Dell Tech World, Microsoft Build and IBM Think. And so I did not have an opportunity to attend Think, but I did get a preview on something that they launched called Concert and Concert leverages the Watsonx AI tech stack, and it’s designed to provide application visibility into application performance, network bottlenecks, and it’s all about and driving improved user experiences through higher levels of orchestration and automation. And I think when this came across the wire, I recall Matt, we had an internal chat within the firm around, “What is this, man? Is it like FD?” As I dug into it, it’s just that, and there are three use cases that I’m going to hit very, very quickly that IBM is promoting out of the gate. And obviously as the platform matures, there’ll be more. But the three initial high potential use cases are application security, risk management, application compliance management and application certificate management. All of those things are very tedious to manage. There’s lots of revisions and certificates. There are security implications to that as well.
And with something that IBM is calling Concert 360, it consolidates all of that into a single view. It is leveraging an AI engine to do that. It’s also integrating generative AI to make the natural language interface that much smoother. So I’m going to leave it at that. What I will say though, what I like about IBM Concert is that I kind of feel like Watson, and Paul may disagree with me, but that Watson’s been trying to find interesting relevant use cases over the years. I remember when it debuted on Jeopardy and it beat Jennings, who I think is the all-time winner on Jeopardy and someone else. That’s when the public really got to know what IBM Watson was. But I think there’ve been some hit or misses over the years. But I think for Concert, I mean, this really could be IBM’s home run from my perspective. Obviously it’s in my coverage area, so I’m going to be a little bit biased about that, but I’d love to get Paul’s take on this.
Paul Smith-Goodson: The early adopters of Concert had really good reports on it in operational efficiency and the platform’s ability to automate routine tasks and provide insights and stuff. I think they’ve got a winner.
Matt Kimball: Yeah. Is Concert, is this an IBM tool for IBM environments or is this a tool that I can use for my applications that are developed on different platforms and running different platforms? Do you guys know?
Paul Smith-Goodson: The platform’s designed to support the compliance with all kinds of industry standards and regulations that give a business the tools that I need. Legal and ethical and all kinds of stuff, so yeah.
Matt Kimball: Okay. Ethics. Who needs ethics? We don’t need to speak in ethics. Excellent.
Will Townsend: All right, let’s move along. That was three minutes for me.
Matt Kimball: That was three minutes. You rocked on that one, man. So thumbs down on the name of your section there because we could have done a lot with-
Will Townsend: I’ll work on it.
Matt Kimball: … on timeliness. All right, here we go. Figure out who this is. Ready? Go. AI reads your brain. I wonder.
Will Townsend: That would be Paul.
Paul Smith-Goodson: This one is actually kind of a fun one. I mean, it’s not fun if you’re in the wrong position, but a paper came out just a couple of days ago on a bilingual brain reading device. It can decode both in Spanish and English. And they put this device into a guy that had a stroke, young guy, 20 years old, and he was bilingual, Spanish and English. And they’ve learned, from doing this, they’ve learned a couple things. One is that the way the brain processes the language, both Spanish and English kind of come from the same area of the brain, and they didn’t realize that before. The guy’s name was Pancho, was 20 years old and lost the ability to speak well. And a neurosurgeon at the University of California was the guy that put this together. And by putting this device into the brain, it can actually read the neural signals and interpret it into a language, either Spanish or English.
The first thing that came out of this device when they put it on him was, “My family is outside.” And like I said, he is bilingual and he felt more comfortable with Spanish, but it came out as English. But anyway, the training system was about 200 words. They got a neural pattern established for each word with electrodes and the initial accuracy, if I remember right, it’s about 88% accurate in determining on using the first word to determine if it’s English or if it’s Spanish and it’s about 75% accurate in decoding the correct sentence.
So it’s pretty neat. I think there’s going to be a lot of usage out of it. If you were traveling the world, eventually you’re traveling the world and need to know how to speak Russian or Chinese or whatever, this thing could evolve to that. One thing that they were able to do, they could switch from… What’s amazing to me, they could switch from one language to the other in the same sentence. It’s like me saying, I speak a little Russian, like me saying …. That’s Russian and German basically in the same sentence. Interesting.
Matt Kimball: So Paul, does this help for non-verbal people as well? I mean, is this a-
Paul Smith-Goodson: Yeah.
Matt Kimball: Okay. And so what’s the output? So I have some device, I have a neurotransmitter in my brain, but I have something that I’m holding in my hand that kind of voices-
Paul Smith-Goodson: External device. Yeah, it’s external. I haven’t gone all the way through the paper, but I just thought it was really interesting.
Matt Kimball: That’s incredible, man.
Paul Smith-Goodson: Yeah. Now what they’re working on is a bunch of different languages, Chinese and Mandarin and Japanese, and it’s really neat.
Matt Kimball: Yeah, so much for, I thought that was my inner voice, huh? I don’t even want… Some of the stuff that runs through my head, there is no way I want it to be displayed or spoken in any language. Not even Pit Latin. All right, let’s go on. We have nine minutes.
Paul Smith-Goodson: Oh, that’s it for me.
Matt Kimball: Hmm? What was that Paul?
Paul Smith-Goodson: I just said that’s it.
Matt Kimball: Oh, that was fantastic. That was a good one. I have to look that one up. Hey, last thing I wanted to talk about, and we treat this as like a round table, earning season’s in full flight. I want to get your thoughts. So everyone’s been reporting out Intel had a decent quarter, AMD had a decent quarter. Dell announced this week, Lenovo announced-
Will Townsend: Marvell announced this week.
Matt Kimball: … last week. Marvell, Nutanix, yeah. Lots of announcements going out. Anybody want to hit on any of these before I give my spiel?
Paul Smith-Goodson: The only thing I can say is if we could go back in time and remove AI from the equation and look forward to now, these would not look like this.
Matt Kimball: No, they would not.
Will Townsend: Yeah, no kidding. So my friend and colleague, Ed Allen, he’s now back at Dell in an executive role. When we were at Dell Tech World, he made a really interesting comment that it seemed like the tech industry was searching for water and AI has become that water. So it’s really supercharging tons of these companies earnings that are focused on AI. And I think all the companies that we mentioned that they’ve got some sort of design on leveraging the gold rush that’s occurring with AI.
Matt Kimball: Yeah, I think that’s a really good way of putting it. They’ve been kind of in the desert looking for that oasis and AI is… I thought it was interesting because just most recently, Dell, they announced they had record revenue for server sales, which they attributed to AI, yet their operating income was down, which was interesting. Because those AI servers are typically very richly configured. And their storage business was flat, which is interesting because storage is the french fries to the compute being the hamburger of the AI world. So you would’ve thought you would’ve seen an increase, which tells me it’s a very competitive space and they must be selling at lower margins than we would’ve expected. And again, because this is so richly configured, you would’ve thought that maybe-
Will Townsend: It’d be the opposite. Yeah.
Matt Kimball: Yeah. Nutanix had a killer quarter. Pure Storage had a killer quarter, both up double digits where the market otherwise wasn’t. I wonder, Paul, to what you’re saying, if you did remove AI, Dell said they had a strong quarter outside of AI on servers as did Lenovo. But I wonder if you remove that AI number, what those revenues would actually look like.
Paul Smith-Goodson: Yeah, it’s affected everything.
Matt Kimball: Yeah.
Paul Smith-Goodson: You mentioned Dell, operating income was down year over year.
Matt Kimball: I’m talking about for ISG, sorry, for the Infrastructure Solutions Group. Yeah, so server storage and networking, that number was down year over year. And not much, it was only down a single percent, but when your revenue is up 42% and you’re attributing it to AI, you would think that operating income would be reflective of that, but it doesn’t seem to be. But I mean, killer numbers. Everyone is reporting just huge growth in the amount of stuff they’re selling. Maybe they’re not selling it for as much, I guess.
Paul Smith-Goodson: The Dell 860 server?
Matt Kimball:Yeah. Yep. That’s a server. It’s their GPU server with NVIDIA. I’m sure they’re going to do something with AMD. I think they already announced it and I know they announced they’re going to do stuff with Gaudi 3 as well.
Paul Smith-Goodson: I was going to just say that’s an example of AI driving something.
Matt Kimball: Yeah. Without a doubt. Yeah, they said their AI server backlog was up 30% year over year, so I mean, clearly they can’t make these servers fast enough. So anyway, interesting season, lots of good numbers coming out. Good to see companies like Marvell doing great. Broadcom is doing great, and it’s going to be fun to watch this over the next few quarters as supply chains start to ease up a little bit on the accelerator front as well. But we’re coming up to the top of the hour and we all turn into pumpkins at the top of the hour, so-
Paul Smith-Goodson: I just want to mention one thing.
Matt Kimball: Yeah, please do.
Paul Smith-Goodson: NVIDIA is a 10-for-1 stock spread.
Matt Kimball: Oh, yeah.
Will Townsend: Yeah. Like next Friday, right? I believe. And have y’all been tracking the stock? So it got as high as boy, 12, 1200 and change and there’s been some profit taken, so it’s sort of down in the thousand range, but an all-time high for the company and yeah, ahead of a 10-for-1 stock split next week.
Matt Kimball: Absolutely incredible. Absolutely incredible. Dell was at one 170 or 180. 179, was it? A record for them. AMD was up around 200. I mean, these companies are just killing it. They’re truly carrying the market. But listen, we talked about a lot of stuff guys, and it was a lot of good stuff and we had a lot of fun. To the 40,000 people that are watching us right now, don’t use anything we said as advice for investment. Please, for the love of God and everything that’s right in this world, do not trust us for investing, okay? We talk about tech, we love tech, we goof around, we give our opinions, but they are not educated. It’s not financial advice. And if you like what you hear from us, please tune in again in two weeks. If you don’t like what you heard from us, don’t tune in, but do your Reddit reviews and/or Twitter reviews. We pick on Will all the time. Let’s do Paul this time, okay?
Will Townsend: Yeah, send it to Paul.
Matt Kimball: Target all your negative energy toward Paul. All right. Okay, Paul, I love your response.
Will Townsend: Paul’s just like, “Whatever.” We love your snark, Matt. We love your snark.
Matt Kimball: Listen, you guys have a wonderful weekend and we will see you again in two weeks. And have fun in Vegas.
Will Townsend: Yes.
Matt Kimball: Paul, keep kicking butt and I’ll be in Boston and Vegas, I’ll see you in Vegas at Discover.
Will Townsend: All right.
Matt Kimball: All right. Thanks guys. Take care.
Will Townsend: Thanks.



